Indonesia Might Solve the Puzzle of Bird Flu Transmission
5121
Disease & Illness > Bird Flu
Mar 1, 2007
Richard Stooker
Indonesia Might Solve the Puzzle of Bird Flu Transmission
Is bird flu being spread more by migrating birds or by people transporting infected poultry?
That's a question being debated by experts, and although it may not seem important, the answer makes a big difference in understanding how to stop the spread of bird flu.
Some experts say that the main reason bird flu has spread from Southeast Asia to the Middle East, several areas of Africa and much of Europe is migratory birds.
Wild ducks are the standard reservoir for avian influenza viruses, meaning it's normal for them to carry various influenza viruses in their intestines. It normally does not affect the ducks themselves, but they can spread it to chickens and other birds.
Supporters of this theory cite the genetic consistency between the strain of H5N1 in the wild birds that died around Quinghai Lake, China in the spring of 2005 and the H5N1 found in dead birds found in Europe.
Some experts say that the bird flu virus is being spread mainly by people. On an international level, by smugglers of exotic birds and importers and exporters of chicken meat (often evading duties and tariffs). On the national level, by business people in the poultry industry transporting infected birds from one location to another.
At stake is a lot of money, planning and effort, because we need to adapt our tactics and strategies in the fight against bird flu to what will be most effective.
If bird flu is spread mainly by migratory birds, we need to monitor and restrict their contact with domestic poultry.
If bird flu is spread mainly by smugglers and transporters, we need to crack down hard on the smugglers and closely regulate and test chickens and eggs before transporting and selling them.
I'm no expert, but I'm putting forth the proposition that Indonesia is the perfect "laboratory" in which to test the validity of these two theories.
Indonesia is perhaps the most weirdly geographically shaped country in the world. It's rivalled by its neighbor to the north, The Philippines, and the Maldives. But it's 17,000 islands spread over thousands of square miles of ocean. On some islands, it shares space with other countries (East Timor, for example).
I'm sure that someone with more resources than I have could create a database to map the path of bird flu across Indonesia and then compare it with the two possible modes of transmission: wild birds and chicken transporters.
Then see which hypothesis best accounts for the facts:
Location of all islands plotted with longitude and latitude, along with all major cities, regional market centers and villages that have had bird flu cases.
Routes of migratory birds.
Location of all known human bird flu cases -- along with dates of infection.
Location of all known chicken bird flu cases -- along with dates of infection.
Location of all known wild fowl bird flu cases -- along with dates their bodies were found.
Genetic sequences of all known human bird flu cases -- together with comparisons with genetic sequences of other nearby infections (found in Thailand, China, Cambodia and Vietnam).
Genetic sequences of all known chicken bird flu cases -- together with comparisons from other Asian countries, plus those found in migratory birds in locations that are both come before and after the routes under which Indonesia lies.
Genetic sequences of all known wildlife bird flu cases -- together with comparisons from all those found in migratory birds in locations that are both come before and after the routes under which Indonesia lies.
All major transportation routes within Indonesia, including highways, airplane routes, ferries and boat routes.
All chicken transport routes.
Most common travel routes for day to day travel. Most people from the capital of Jakarta will travel only to rural areas where they have family or to vacation/resort spots. Most rural residents will travel only to Jakarta or to the nearest regional marketplace. (This is the norm in developing countries and with Indonesia extreme geography and ethnic diversity, it's very unlikely that anybody travels from rural province to rural province for pleasure.)
Most common business travel routes from province to province, especially transporting chicken and eggs.
Map all this data into some data mining software and it should soon clear whether bird flu -- in Indonesia, anyway -- is spreading through migrating birds or human transportation of chickens -- or both.
That's a question being debated by experts, and although it may not seem important, the answer makes a big difference in understanding how to stop the spread of bird flu.
Some experts say that the main reason bird flu has spread from Southeast Asia to the Middle East, several areas of Africa and much of Europe is migratory birds.
Wild ducks are the standard reservoir for avian influenza viruses, meaning it's normal for them to carry various influenza viruses in their intestines. It normally does not affect the ducks themselves, but they can spread it to chickens and other birds.
Supporters of this theory cite the genetic consistency between the strain of H5N1 in the wild birds that died around Quinghai Lake, China in the spring of 2005 and the H5N1 found in dead birds found in Europe.
Some experts say that the bird flu virus is being spread mainly by people. On an international level, by smugglers of exotic birds and importers and exporters of chicken meat (often evading duties and tariffs). On the national level, by business people in the poultry industry transporting infected birds from one location to another.
At stake is a lot of money, planning and effort, because we need to adapt our tactics and strategies in the fight against bird flu to what will be most effective.
If bird flu is spread mainly by migratory birds, we need to monitor and restrict their contact with domestic poultry.
If bird flu is spread mainly by smugglers and transporters, we need to crack down hard on the smugglers and closely regulate and test chickens and eggs before transporting and selling them.
I'm no expert, but I'm putting forth the proposition that Indonesia is the perfect "laboratory" in which to test the validity of these two theories.
Indonesia is perhaps the most weirdly geographically shaped country in the world. It's rivalled by its neighbor to the north, The Philippines, and the Maldives. But it's 17,000 islands spread over thousands of square miles of ocean. On some islands, it shares space with other countries (East Timor, for example).
I'm sure that someone with more resources than I have could create a database to map the path of bird flu across Indonesia and then compare it with the two possible modes of transmission: wild birds and chicken transporters.
Then see which hypothesis best accounts for the facts:
Location of all islands plotted with longitude and latitude, along with all major cities, regional market centers and villages that have had bird flu cases.
Routes of migratory birds.
Location of all known human bird flu cases -- along with dates of infection.
Location of all known chicken bird flu cases -- along with dates of infection.
Location of all known wild fowl bird flu cases -- along with dates their bodies were found.
Genetic sequences of all known human bird flu cases -- together with comparisons with genetic sequences of other nearby infections (found in Thailand, China, Cambodia and Vietnam).
Genetic sequences of all known chicken bird flu cases -- together with comparisons from other Asian countries, plus those found in migratory birds in locations that are both come before and after the routes under which Indonesia lies.
Genetic sequences of all known wildlife bird flu cases -- together with comparisons from all those found in migratory birds in locations that are both come before and after the routes under which Indonesia lies.
All major transportation routes within Indonesia, including highways, airplane routes, ferries and boat routes.
All chicken transport routes.
Most common travel routes for day to day travel. Most people from the capital of Jakarta will travel only to rural areas where they have family or to vacation/resort spots. Most rural residents will travel only to Jakarta or to the nearest regional marketplace. (This is the norm in developing countries and with Indonesia extreme geography and ethnic diversity, it's very unlikely that anybody travels from rural province to rural province for pleasure.)
Most common business travel routes from province to province, especially transporting chicken and eggs.
Map all this data into some data mining software and it should soon clear whether bird flu -- in Indonesia, anyway -- is spreading through migrating birds or human transportation of chickens -- or both.
Article Source: http://www.articlerich.com
c 2006 by Richard Stooker Richard Stooker is the author of How to Protect Yourself and Your Family From Bird Flu and Bird Flu Blog
Write a Review
Add to My Favorite
Refer it to Friend
Report Article
Other links owned by this user
If you want to trust you and your family's health to the government -- you deserve what happens to you. The United States Homeland Security Council in early May 2006 released a 233 page report called the Strategy for Pandemic Influenza
Category:
Bobby Fischer ate meat, cheese, hardboiled eggs and herring. Drank ice water, tomato juice and cola. Boris Spassky ate sandwiches and drank coffee and orange juice. Therefore, during their epic World Championship Chess
Category:
For years, world class chess players have prepared for important tournaments by exercising. But few chess players do so in an optimum way. Serious chess players are certainly very intellectual, and not inclined to keep up a regular regimen
Category:
Is bird flu being spread more by migrating birds or by people transporting infected poultry? That's a question being debated by experts, and although it may not seem important, the answer makes a big difference in understanding how to stop
Category:
Although the famous Man Versus Machine matches of Garry Kasparov against IBM's Deep Blue superr and the upcoming match of Vladimir Kramnik against Deep Fritz coming November 25, 2006 get the media attention, this article is more about how
Category:
International travel has always had its special health challenges, but until recently most travelers were not afraid of anything worse than diarrhea. Bird flu's changed that. The bird flu H5N1 virus has now been found from
Category:
If nothing else, the bird flu scare should remind us not to take our immune systems for granted. According to U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services, Michael Leavitt, it'll take 6 months after a contagious strain of bird flu is
Category:
Somewhere in Southeast Asia (or Africa, the MidEast, Europe etc) . . . A hen clucks and shifts around in her perch. She sniffs and sneezes. Inside the lining of her respiratory tract and lungs, millions of influenza viruses
Category:
Yes, sure chess is good for developing he abiliy o hink, o reason, o ponder, o calculae and analyze. Sure i develops he abiliy o read and remember. To look and hink ahead, o carefully reason ou and foresee he consequences of acions and
Category:
Your ain needs oxygen -- and lots of it. Your ain uses up 20% of all the oxygen you eathe in. To play your best game of chess, you need lots of oxygen freely flowing to your ain. 40% of your body's energy is burned in your
Category:
You see a lot of wild and crazy ates for this. Yet, the truth is, there's no simple answer. It depends on a lot of things -- and the most important factors are still unknown. First of all, I don't put any stock in the simplistic
Category:
Several months ago, a cat in Germany caught bird flu -- and pet owners throughout Europe dumped ir poor dogs and cats. I trust you have more concern for animals under your care than that, and re are ways to reduce risk that
Category:
Your prospect is actively hiding from you. One of the biggest mistakes you can make when choosing a copywriter is to hire one the same way you'd pick a champion archer. In archery, you should look for the bowman with the
Category:
There've always been risks to hunting and fishing -- and smart hunters and fishers have always been aware of them and taken steps to minimize the risks. Just as you now practice gun safety, you must now be aware that there is new risk --
Category:
Why? During a bird pandemic you d remain as isolated from everybody outside your family as possible. Therefore, you d shop only for necessities: food, water, fuel and medicine. Where? Therefore, you
Category:
There's a new and so far lile-known way o cach bird flu. By waer. One major oubreak of bird flu among wild birds occurred in he middle of 2005 around Qinghai Lake, in China. Recenly, wild birds in ha area have again
Category:
To the best of our knowledge, the history of chess started out in Northern India about 1500 years ago, where it was called turanga. There're allegations that it actually started in China, perhaps as long as 3000 years ago. So perhaps
Category:
How can you know whether your or a loved one ha bird flu or jut a cae of ordinary flu? That' not a imple quetion to anwer. Frankly, the only 100% way i to have body ecretion teted by a World Health Organization (WHO) laboratory
Category:
The bird flu virus can be compared to a monkey with a typewriter. And that's why it's getting more and more dangerous. You may have heard the old observation that if you give enough monkeys a keyboard, eventually one will -- just by
Category:
On the face of it, the answer is obviously yes. Except for the brief period when Bobby Fischer held the title, the World Championship was in the hands of Soviet players from the first tournament following the end of World War 2 until the collapse of the
Category:
Other links at Disease & Illness > Bird Flu
Is bird flu being spread more by migrating birds or by people transporting infected poultry? That's a question being debated by experts, and although it may not seem important, the answer makes a big difference in understanding how to stop
Category:
How can you know whether your or a loved one ha bird flu or jut a cae of ordinary flu? That' not a imple quetion to anwer. Frankly, the only 100% way i to have body ecretion teted by a World Health Organization (WHO) laboratory
Category:
According to The Navhind Times dated 8th May 2006, USA is unprepared for the Bird Flu pandemic. A fact that the United States Health and Human Services Secretary, Mr. Michael Leavitt
Category:
The bird flu virus can be compared to a monkey with a typewriter. And that's why it's getting more and more dangerous. You may have heard the old observation that if you give enough monkeys a keyboard, eventually one will -- just by
Category:
Somewhere in Southeast Asia (or Africa, the MidEast, Europe etc) . . . A hen clucks and shifts around in her perch. She sniffs and sneezes. Inside the lining of her respiratory tract and lungs, millions of influenza viruses
Category:
Site Sponsor
Directory Statistics
Articles: 68228
Categories: 501
Yahoo Entertainment
