Lead In Children's and Adult's Jewelry: The Untold Story
50612
Society
Oct 19, 2007
Circlemanifesto
Lead In Children's and Adult's Jewelry: The Untold Story
FJ: Can you tell me something about Center for Environmental Health (CEH) became involved in the outing of high lead in children's jewelry? Michael Green, Executive Director (MG): The mission of The Center for Environmental Health (CEH) is protecting communities and families from toxic chemicals. We were looking for things children come into contact with that might have lead. Lead is a serious neurotoxin that can cause learning disabilities, behavioral problems and brain damage. In 2004 we discovered tested lead in jewelry and found it was extensive. FJ: Once you found the problem, what happened then? MG: We filed a suit against 100 large companies in 2004. I think a couple months after that we filed our first legal notices, 150 million pieces of lead-contaminated cheap jewelry was pulled from gumball machines around the country. I assume that the lead jewelry came mainly from China, since that has been in the news. MG: The gum ball jewelry was made in India. Lead is used as a raw material because it is cheap and easy to use in metal. In PVC plastic it's used as a pigment and a stabilizer to hold other chemicals together. FJ: Did these companies knowingly sold lead children's jewelry? MG: Hell yes. You can quote me. The buyers from Wal-Mart and Disney definitely knew about the lead issue. All the manufacturers knew. They refer to different metals by the percentage of lead that they have in it. Their basic attitude was, "Well, there's not much lead in it, who cares because everyone else is doing it." After the initial suit, you continued to push the issue when even recently is in the news. Yes. We went to California legislature and made the settlement law. California is 10% of the market in the country. You are not going to have two lines-one in CA and one nationally so the legislation should create a new national standard that may force the small companies to comply as well Having said this-who is testing for this jewelry now? Only companies party to the settlement. The Feds don't have resources or the will-not with Bush in office, so there's inadequate enforcement. Is crazy, but it is a small nonprofit in CA that was joined by the Attorney General of CA. Recently Arnold Schwarzenegger signed a lead protection for children bill into law. FJ: Your activism brought you the House of Representatives. What happened in Washington that strikes you even now? MG: I was sitting behind the CEO of Mattel, Robert Eckert, watching him testify. He said that he didn't know and that he was sorry. It was very much like Harry Truman. The buck stops here. "We're good guys and have white hats." The key point is that he said, "We recalled 9 million toys, so you can trust us to do the right thing" on Wednesday to Congress. Then on Friday, two days later, in Hong Kong, Eckert did a press conference with the Chinese counterpart to our Consumer Products Safety Commission - they regulate lead in consumer products. He apologized to Chinese for harming the Chinese brand by accusing it of having lead! He must have known on Wednesday that he was going to say that on Friday. This very low ethical standard was all planned out in advance. Most articles were complementary of Eckert on Friday. What happened on Saturday was not well covered. Saturday newspapers are the least read. There was not much blowback. Looking at the list of defendants on your website, I was surprised. I don't recall hearing about Federated, Saks and Nordstrom selling lead jewelry. I thought this issue was mainly around children's jewelry. Caroline Cox, Research Director (CC): Clearly some of the jewelry we tested is more oriented to children than adults, but it is a hard distinction to make. Little girls put on their Mom's jewelry. Parents give their kids jewelry to wear. A parent talking on the phone might give a baby a bracelet that will end up in the baby's mouth. Kids chew on jewelry all the time. We definitely found jewelry for adults priced in the $40 to $60 range. Recently, much of the costume jewelry for sale was made from alloys that contained fairly large amounts of lead. In a published Ashland University Study, jewelry purchased in four different towns was tested for lead content. They found that the average piece of children's jewelry was 44% lead. I think around 40% of the jewelry was over 80% lead. The idea of what you put behind the plating does not matter was tragically refuted by the boy in MN who swallowed a plated charm and died. The plating was dissolved in the stomach. Any plated piece of jewelry, costume jewelry, probably has a chance of having a lead content; for example, fake pearl jewelry. It turns out that the coating that makes something look like a pearl can have a high lead coating. Lead is absorbed in the skin but usually this is not major-but if your child handled lead coated fake pearls and his hands ended up in his mouth, he could be ingesting lead. FJ: Right now these companies are selling adult lead jewelry. Perhaps they have marked it down? Where does it end up - Dollar stores? CC: March 1st, 2008 is the off the shelf date for all lead jewelry in stores, though some of the retails have agreed to accelerated compliance dates. Shipping compliance date was Aug 1st. FJ: But this is only for California, right? Is there any way to assure that California stores are not just migrating product illegal in CA to other regions? There's no national legislation around lead in jewelry, is there? CC: Our experience with working with other industries is that most of the time the companies are not interested in trying to manufacture or distribute a separate product for the California market. Currently the Consumer Product Safety Commission has proposed draft regulations about lead in jewelry, but they are not final. There are also a number of bills before Congress that limit lead in children's products. FJ: Suppose you or your child has a piece of jewelry that might contain lead. What do you do? CC: We get a lot of questions from parents who are concerned about the jewelry that they already own. It is not really expensive to test jewelry for lead. You can use a test kit used for testing lead in paint available in any hardware store, so if you have a favorite piece of jewelry it is pretty straight forward to figure out of there's [delete apostrophe] problem.
Marc Choyt is President of Reflective Images, an award winning jewelry company, www.celticjewelry.com that sells wedding rings sourced by artisan designers online at www.artisanweddingrings.com. His company produces fair, eco-sourced, fairly trade jewelry. Marc also authors www.fairjewelry.org supporting green, fair trade, socially responsible jewelry practices.
send email to Circlemanifesto
Write a Review
Add to My Favorite
Refer it to Friend
Report Article
Other links owned by this user
Those in the jewelry industry interested in a fair and ethical sourcing can differentiate themselves from the industry as a whole, and create a new market category with tremendous potential. This article, based on the book, Blue Ocean Strategy, gives some
Category:
There's a great deal of confusion and misleading information around fair trade jewelry. While there is no such thing as third party certified fair trade jewelry, many companies sell fair trade jewelry. This interview with Carmen Iezzi, director of the Fai
Category:
Third party certified fair trade jewelry does not exist; yet if you google fair trade jewelry millions of sites come up. Written for the consumer and the trade, this short article, extensively researched and referenced, sorts though the concept of fair tr
Category:
The blood diamond issue is no longer in the news, yet these diamonds still are widely traded. This insider's view, written by a jeweler, gives a present day and historical context to the diamond trade. Ultimately the consumer concerned about ethics is emp
Category:
The Center for Environmental Health (CEH), a small NGO, first discovered high lead content in jewelry. They filed law suit and helped to pushed through legislation. Michael Green, the Executive Director and Caroline Cox, Research Director, discuss how pre
Category:
For the many people committing to marriage today are deeply concerned about the state of the environment, green weddings are an increasingly popular option. This article gives a wide range of references which can provide seed ideas for those interested in
Category:
Steve D'Esposito, executive director of Earthworks, discusses his organization of a multi-sector Ethical Jewelry Summit on socially and environmentally sourced jewelry production. This article discusses some of the issues involved in the very early stages
Category:
The author, who owns a jewelry company, argues that those in the jewelry industry attempting to fend off critiques from NGOs are actually doing more harm than good. He calls for to a truthful reckoning of the atrocities of environmental and social upheava
Category:
Often the meaning of Celtic jewelry is based more on marketing than an understanding of symbolism. This article discusses the true meaning of knot motifs from a universal, sacred geometry perspective. By considering the elements that make up the knot patt
Category:
Knot work designs are thought of as "Celtic," but actually, they are found all over the world. This article, by the president of a leading Celtic jewelry company, discusses his experiences finding these knot motifs all over the world starting in South Ind
Category:
Laurens Mare, the CEO of the South African Jewelry Counsel, discusses Vukani-Ubuntu, a Non-Profit Organization that trains people from rural townships into the commercial jewelry trade. This social entrepreneurial effort applies fair trade principal of ec
Category:
Other links at Society
Almost invariably you see cigars matched together with alcoholic beverages such as Scotch, brandy, or rum. For many people the proper combination is to match up a good cigar with a sweet tasting alcoholic drink.
Category:
This is particularly true if you will be flying to a destination and then securing a rental car.
Category:
If eyes are the windows to your soul, your shoes are the windows to your character. Being well dressed doesn't stop from your shirt to your pants. It goes right down to your shoes, too. Thus, don't miss out on your shoes. Always take time to shine them on
Category:
One of the first questions that a budding autograph collector must ask is themselves is how much they can afford to spend on them. This is an essential question for collectors of any item really when you think about it.
Category:
The process of making fake IDs has been something that's been done for many years usually in the privacy of someone's home in secret quarters.
Category:
Site Sponsor
Directory Statistics
Articles: 68205
Categories: 501
Yahoo Entertainment
