Annuities: Don't Put Your IRA In A Variable Annuity
29868
Finance > Investing
Jun 20, 2007
voudrie12
Annuities: Don't Put Your IRA In A Variable Annuity
If you've talked to a broker or agent about rolling over your retirement account, there's a good chance the advisor recommended you invest in a Variable Annuity. Don't do it! I believe the only reason a variable annuity is recommended for an IRA is so the advisor can earn more money. Let me explain. There's a high probability that if an advisor doesn't recommend an Equity-Indexed Annuity for your IRA rollover, a Variable Annuity will be recommended instead. 'There are so many advantages to a variable annuity versus a mutual fund', you're told. I disagree. It's advantageous for the advisor, not the investor. In this article, I'll debunk the two main arguments used in selling variable annuities. First, that you don't pay a commission and secondly, the importance of the death benefit guarantee. I'll explain how you pay dearly for both. One of the main sales 'hooks' used in selling a variable annuity is that you don't have to pay a commission. That can be very compelling when compared to a mutual fund in which you pay the all the commission up-front. Many advisors will even say that they get compensated by the insurance company, not you. Do you really believe that? Insurance companies are not charitable organizations. If they are paying the broker, they'll recoup those costs from you--the costs are just hidden so you don't think you're paying a commission. The second main argument for using a variable annuity for an IRA is the death benefit (not offered with a mutual fund). "That way you'll never have to worry about your beneficiary getting less than you invested", the thoughtful advisor says. This feature may seem nice, but you end up paying through the nose for it. With all variable annuities there is a Mortality and Risk Expense (M&E) charge. Most variable annuities sold through commission-based advisors have an M&E charge of 1.45%. This is an annual fee that is charged against the entire value of the account, not the original investment. On a $500,000 investment that amounts to $7,250 the first year. If your account doubles in 10 years, you'd pay $14,500 that year. Note that the M&E charge is in addition to the underlying money management fees charged by the people actually making the investment decisions. Their fees can range from .70% to 1.5%. All told, the fees associated with most variable annuities range from 2-3% per year. That's a 2-3% hole you start in each year. That's $10,000-$15,000 each year on a $500,000 investment--and that expense increases as the value of the account increases. Do you really think it costs $10,000-$15,000 a year to cover the cost of the insurance associated with the death benefit? Of course not. The full $500,000 in our example isn't really being insured, either. They're only insuring the amount of loss. So if the investment loses 10%, the actual amount of 'insurance' is $50,000. Even when the investment is worth more than you paid you continue to be charge M&E. So the death benefit associated with a variable annuity is either the most expensive insurance you'll ever buy, or it pays for more than insurance. The M&E is where the insurance company makes their money. More importantly, the M&E is where the insurance company gets paid back the money it paid your advisor in commission. Here's proof. The M&E on variable annuities offered by Vanguard (in which no one earns a commission) is about .60%. That's over three quarters of a percent less than the 1.45% being paid to the commission-based advisor. The real reason that you are recommended a variable annuity for your IRA isn't that it's better for you. It's because it's better for the advisor. If you invest $500,000 in a commission-based mutual fund, the advisor's gross commission will only be about $10,000. The same investment in a variable annuity would yield gross commission to the advisor of $30,000-$35,000 or more! If an advisor can earn 3 times more by getting you to invest in a variable annuity instead of a mutual fund, which do you think will be recommended?
Nationally-syndicated financial columnist and Certified Financial Planner Jeffrey Voudrie provides personal, in-depth money management services and advice to select private clients throughout the USA. He will answer your financial question FREE at http://www.guardingyourwealth.net
send email to voudrie12
Write a Review
Add to My Favorite
Refer it to Friend
Report Article
Other links owned by this user
Don't cancel your life insurance policy without reading this first! Depending on your situation, you may be losing tens of thousands of dollars if you do. If you have a life insurance policy that you no longer can afford or need, consider selling the poli
Category:
Few topics confuse investors more than figuring out what estate-related documents they need. Living Wills, Living Trusts, and Powers of Attorney are just a few of the terms that most find hard to define, let alone understand.
Category:
Providing for adequate health care is one of the top concerns for today's seniors. And yet, many find themselves coming up short when that need is for long term care. With costs skyrocketing and government purse strings tightening, planning for such care
Category:
At some point you will need to make changes to your investment portfolio. Often, investors and their advisors make wholesale changes all at once. But that's not really in your best interest. Read on to find out how to successfully adjust your portfolio.
Category:
You may be paying too much for health, life or long-term care insurance! I know because a life insurance company recently tried to charge me double. My experience may save you money and keep you from being turned down the next time you apply for insurance
Category:
One of the biggest mistakes I frequently see investors make is needlessly losing control of their money. Any time you pay a hefty commission or face surrender penalties in order to get YOUR money you lose control.
Category:
My mother-in-law recently passed away after a long and courageous battle with cancer. Throughout her battle, our family had to deal with many emotional and legal issues. Over the next couple weeks, I'll be discussing these in more detail in the hope that
Category:
Every investor would like to increase their income without compromising their stability. Maybe that's why Equity Indexed Annuities (EIAs) have become so popular, because of their promise of providing a stable income stream.
Category:
If you've talked to a broker or agent about rolling over your retirement account, there's a good chance the advisor recommended you invest in a Variable Annuity. Don't do it! I believe the only reason a variable annuity is recommended for an IRA is so the
Category:
Recent legislation in Congress may make it even more difficult for seniors to qualify for government-paid long-term care coverage. If you don't take action now, you may be setting you and your family up for a Long Term Nightmare!
Category:
Perhaps the only area outside the financial world where performance is so closely measured is the Olympics. Competition is fierce, and with events measured to the hundredths of a second, athletes go to great lengths to gain even the slightest edge. The Ol
Category:
Doris from Minnesota is considering transferring her assets to her son so they won't be lost to Medicaid should she need assisted-living or nursing home care. Is that the right move? If so, what's the best way to do it? Read on to find out.
Category:
Everybody wants to find the secret to investing on Wall Street. But the truth is, you don't have to be a genius to be a successful equity investor
Category:
You should continue to grow your nest egg even when retired--unless you've been blessed with more money than you will ever spend! Last week I discussed in detail how retirees can boost their income without taking on unnecessary risk.
Category:
Q. Jeff, I've been approached by someone touting the benefits of equity indexed annuity with "Company-X". They say my money will be safe, there's a minimum return and a cap with a participation rate of 100%.
Category:
One email in particular recently caught my eye. And it wasn't from being flamed by irate insurance agents (I got plenty of those!), or emails from thankful consumers, pleased the public is being warned about equity-indexed annuities' pitfalls.
Category:
Millions of retirees expect to rely on Medicaid to cover the cost of their long-term care needs. If you or your parents have that expectation then you must read this article. You shouldn't rely on this program and by doing so you may end up becoming depen
Category:
Equity-Linked Certificates of Deposit are a safer, low-cost alternative for those who must have an Equity-Indexed Annuity type of investment. These little-known investments allow you to participate in the growth of the market index while your principal is
Category:
Seniors in your community may be targets of financial charlatans. I've received a number of disturbing reports recently from seniors about the abusive tactics of some advisors. Their actions are not only unethical, but they border on the criminal. You mus
Category:
If you're getting ready to retire with a large IRA rollover, or your current IRA account is nearing the end of any surrender penalties, chances are you'll be pitched this product. So this week I'm going to reveal more secrets about the truth behind the va
Category:
Other links at Finance > Investing
Have you started investing yet? I will be the first to admit that I never even considered investing in anything in the past. What is the point?
Category:
Real estate investing in tax lien certificate is a great way to earn safe, passive and massive cash flow.
Category:
To become a successful property investor you need to educate yourself. This article discusses the issues you need to consider prior to attending a property investment course.
Category:
The battle between investment activity in the internet and real world became enough tangible. I decided to broaden the subject and tell the beginners (making professionals thinking) about the differences and vice versa similarities between investment acti
Category:
Site Sponsor
Directory Statistics
Articles: 68214
Categories: 501
Yahoo Entertainment
