Alcohol Dependence Isn't an Equal Opportunity Condition, Nor is One-Size-Fits-All Treatment Effect
27938
Health & Fitness
Jun 18, 2007
DrEdder
Alcohol Dependence Isn't an Equal Opportunity Condition, Nor is One-Size-Fits-All Treatment Effect
Despite all of the marketing hype to the contrary, those who succumb to alcohol abuse, dependence and addiction aren't equally represented across ages, genders, nationalities, religions, or any other demographic. There are in fact wide variations between different populations and at different times. So, while it is true that it's possible to find an 80 year old, white, Jewish, female alcoholic, you will not find as many of them, either in numbers or percentages, as you will drunken, young, privileged, college fraternity brothers. What's the point? That there is a great deal of difference between individuals who suffer from the ill effects of alcohol's destructive side, and that treating everyone as being equal results in treatment that helps no one very effectively. If potential clients are being lumped together then at least they should be lumped into groupings that have some validity and usefulness. Not just into one group, alcoholics, in need of the one true 12-Step based treatment. Additionally, some individuals are capable of reversing their dependence and moderating their alcohol use. It isn't easy to do, is certainly politically incorrect, and nearly universally rejected by American treatment programs who dislike suggestions that complicate matters with accountability. The questions then become ones about whether or not there are any categories that can be used to treat individuals more effectively. And are there other types of treatment? The answers, ones which a few facilities acknowledge, are yes, and yes. Even some obvious differences have been noted and occasionally incorporated. Gender comes to mind and it has long been known that effectively reaching women takes different approaches than reaching men. It's not universally true of course, generalizations aren't, but for the most part progress is more certain when gender is taken into consideration. Other factors are also important. The degree to which alcohol has intruded into a client's life will have an effect on any attempts to moderate, for example. The client's motivation is a primary factor in making change successfully and, no, coercion is not motivation. Support from others is helpful but change remains personal and "others" will always include people, perhaps most of them, with a vested interest in clients' failure. When you are contemplating and planning change, you will need to catalogue your resources along with your problems. Most programs will only focus on diagnostic labels that justify your supposed appropriateness for their particular program. It is vital that you be at least equally concerned with your strengths, interests, abilities, and future, and advocate for your own self-interest. Ultimately successful change is up to you, not to any program. You can find invaluable help and significantly shorten to time it takes, the cost, and the uncertainly. But results will be yours. Make sure they are the ones you want, need, and deserve.
Dr. Edward Wilson has been developing and providing alternative alcohol counseling, including moderation, sincve 1990. He is the co-founder and Clinical Director of Your Empowering Solutions, Inc, located in S. California. http://www.non12step.com
send email to DrEdder
Write a Review
Add to My Favorite
Refer it to Friend
Report Article
Other links owned by this user
Ready to leave meetings and forever recovery behind? Is it possible or even desirable? Here's the answer.
Category:
Tired of being labeled and referred to one-size-fits-all treatment? You can end, or moderate, your alcohol use without lifelong recovery.
Category:
There is a wide range of solutions to alcohol related problems if you look hard enough. Don't fall for the ads, myths, and depressing outcomes.
Category:
Can't decide on a treatment program? Confused by the hype? Here's what to ask!
Category:
It isn't necessary to sign up for permanent "recovery" and endless meetings in order to end, or moderate, alcohol abuse.
Category:
Considering rehab and don't know what form will be most effective? Most practical? Here's an answer with what factors to consider.
Category:
Anti-craving medication is available as treatment support. It won't cure the problem but it can help when used with CBT in a well designed plan.
Category:
Ready to select a treatment option? Make sure you are getting your money's worth!
Category:
Tired of meetings and endless "recover"? Perhaps it's time to throw away the crutches - but is it possible?
Category:
11. Alcohol Dependence Isn't an Equal Opportunity Condition, Nor is One-Size-Fits-All Treatment Effect
Feeling pressured to accept a label instead of services that fit? You're not alone, but there are alternatives.
Category:
Wondering if Treatment might work for you? Consider the possibilities of matching services to your needs and interests, not you to the service offered.
Category:
Wondering how to match your needs with a treatment program? Some programs are offering new and more effective options.
Category:
Alcohol's anti-anxiety properties, with nicotine's counteracting antidepressent properties, make for a seductive but deadly mix. But it can be, and often has been, beaten.
Category:
Other links at Health & Fitness
In fact, aerobic exercise is far more effective at helping you lose weight then strength training, although a home gym can help you build up your muscle mass which can accelerate your weight loss in addition to the aerobic exercises that you do.
Category:
Tired of constant chest pain and indigestion? Article discusses some steps that can be taken to reduce heartburn.
Category:
It is said that a handful of Goji Berries in the morning will make you happy all day...
Category:
When the Department for Education and Skills in Britain considered adding fish oil supplements to the curriculum at local schools in 2006, it caused quite a stir. All questions of legality aside, the idea that this would even be a step that was considered
Category:
Perhaps the first fighter ever in MMA history has died after a fight. Will this change the sport and bring more criticizem to a sport that is surrounded in controversy?
Category:
Site Sponsor
Directory Statistics
Articles: 68252
Categories: 501
Yahoo Entertainment
